"No, kid, I'm just asking you to take a closer look at your surroundings. Think about the people you've been consigned to help out."

Unfortunately, Hayner's insight check came up 1. This is so off the mark it's kind of astounding, but all of Hayner's current evidence now points to this guy being Garfield in a very clever disguise.

"Think about whether or not you really can trust them. They're not the people they appear to be."